OK…Here it is, FINALLY! Version 1.0. Open to critique, suggestions, feedback, and input.
Use the following TWELVE questions to “score” the item you are evaluating. I’ve scored Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag, and Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag, as examples.
All I hope to promote here is CONSCIOUS CONSUMPTION.
Q1. Is it made from recycled/pre-used materials?
2. 100% (made from recycled materials)
1. Less than 100%, but greater than 50%
0. 0%/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0 (Unless I see hard-evidence)
Q2. Is it easy to recycle/make into another product?
2. 100% (can be recycled)
1. Less than 100%, but greater than 50%
0. 0%/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown; assume difficult)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown; assume difficult)
Q3. Can it be easily broken-down and returned without harm to the environment at the very end of its life-cycle?
2. 100% (can be easily broken-down/returned without harm to the environment)
1. Less than 100%, but greater than 50%
0. 0%/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown, assume no)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown, assume no)
Q4. Is it environmentally-considerate to maintain/keep in shape?
2. Yes (no chemicals involved)
1. Kind-of (some chemicals involved)
0. No (significant chemicals involves)/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 1
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 2
Q5. Can it be used for a long-time? (Is it durable?)
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 1
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q6. Will it be used for a long-time? (Is it timeless – e.g. not the latest fashion-fad and therefore won’t be put in the back of the closet after one/two uses?)
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0.5
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q7. Material Preparation Process: Getting the materials your item is made from, into the “state” they need to be in, in order to begin item construction.
2. (Based on appearances*) Not significantly energy and/or chemically intensive
1. (Based on appearances*) Somewhat energy and/or chemically intensive
0. (Based on appearances*) Extremely energy and/or chemically intensive/Unknown
Appearance indicators: Actual material (e.g. bamboo, cotton, plastic, etc.), roughness vs. smoothness, number of colors, types of colors, coatings, etc.
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0
Q8. Manufacturing/Construction Process: The construction of your item.
2. (Based on appearances*) Not significantly energy and/or chemically intensive
1. (Based on appearances*) Somewhat energy and/or chemically intensive
0. (Based on appearances*) Extremely energy and/or chemically intensive/Unknown
Appearance indicators: Machine-made vs. hand-made, number of different materials used, number of different “parts”, number of seems, etc.
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q9. Transportation – A. Source Location to Manufacturing/Construction Location: Where are the materials sourced vs. where is the item constructed?
2. Not significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)
1. Significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)
0. Extremely significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0
Q10. Transportation – B. Manufacturing/Construction Location to Consumer: Where is the item constructed vs. where you resided at the time of purchase?
2. Not significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)
1. Significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)
0. Extremely significant (distance traveled, transportation vehicles used)/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 1
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0
Q11. Are you supporting good employment practices, by buying this product?
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown)
Q12. Are you supporting a disadvantaged group of people/community, by buying this product?
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 0 (Unknown)
TOTAL SCORE:
(NO additional personal measures.)
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 3.5 (out of a possible total of 20)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 5 (out of a possible total of 20)
Additional Personal Measures (Dependent on Consumer):
(These are my own additional personal measures. Add whatever other measures you consider during your purchasing decision process.)
Q13. Compact/travel-friendly – e.g. can it be folded/squashed so it doesn’t take up a lot of space?
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q14. Is it “appealing to the eye” and therefore, will it promote further usage? (Remember, “beauty lies in the eye of the beholder.”)
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q15. Does it do the “job” better than anything else you currently own?
1. Yes
0. No
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
Q16. Is it worth the price it’s being sold for?
1. Yes
0. No/Unknown
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 0 (Only because I made the decision not to buy it already; I already have something that performs the job of the Mimi bag (see Q15).)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 1
TOTAL SCORE:
(WITH additional personal measures.)
Mimi the Sardine’s, “The Shopper” bag = 3.5 (out of a possible total of 24)
Reisenthel’s, “Mini Maxi Shopper” bag = 9 (out of a possible total of 24)